Are Stupid Decisions Sins?

I was listening to the story of a guy who was riding his motorcycle 140mph when he lost control and crashed. His body skid across the payment at an unbelievable speed until he hit a poll. I won’t go into the details of his injuries or how he survived. I’ll only say that he survived, and his injuries were extensive. He’s missing parts of his body, can’t use the restroom, his body is destroyed.

This led me to a thought: was it a sin for him to drive his motorcycle at that ridiculous speed?

What separates sin and stupidity?

Let’s break down that first question a little more, was it a sin to drive a motorcycle at an unsafe speed? Is it a sin to break the speed limit? Is it a sin to break a law? The answer is no, it is not necessarily a sin to break the law.  People and governments make laws and people and governments are corrupt. I could elaborate on this, but I think we all agree. There were some “laws” in World War 2 Germany that were evil. Enough said there.

So it wasn’t a sin to speed on a motorcycle.

But was it stupid?

I think the answer is a resounding YES. It was stupid to drive a motorcycle at 140mph.

Was it a sin to put his body, a gift from God, in such a dangerous position? His decisions that led to destroying a gift from God, were those decisions sinful?

When I had my ATV accident (LINK) was I sinning? No, I don’t think I was…and yet… Yet, was it stupid to be on an ATV without a helmet? In hindsight, of course. Most would say of course even without hindsight.

Is it a sin to do something stupid, knowing it’s stupid, and not caring? I don’t know… I think I knew it was stupid to ride on an ATV without a helmet, and I still did it. Am I stupid or was I sinning? Or both?

What about those on the ATV also not wearing helments who finished that day without any injury? Was their choice not to wear a helmet a sin?

I return to the question, was it a sin for someone to make decisions that he knew were dangerous and ultimately led to destroying a gift from God?

I think the answer is no. I think that’s the answer because he didn’t know he was going to destroy his body and that wasn’t ultimately his goal. I didn’t know not wearing a helmet that day would actually risk my life, even if I knew it was dangerous or there was a chance of injury, I didn’t know it would flip and I would get seriously injured.

Here’s where an important line is drawn. Sin is knowingly doing something wrong. Knowing that what one is doing is wrong, and still doing it. Sin is conscious, intentional wrongdoing. Specifically sin is willfully disobeying God’s commandments.

I think an interesting thing to consider is that sin is always stupid. This is true on so many levels. Sin is knowing an all-loving Father that only wants your best has advised you of something, and you ignore it, whether due to a belief that you know more than Him or simple disobedience. This assumes a person understands that God loves them and wants the best for them. If the person doesn’t understand that, it makes their decisions less likely to be sins. This is where the principle that with added light and knowledge comes more responsibility applies, because the individual has more awareness of how their decisions are wrong.

I believe this is why some in the church feel an overwhelming feeling of guilt that they often blame the church for. Blaming the church is kind of like blaming God. They are mad that they know what they’re doing is wrong, they still want to do it, and this causes a conflict to the soul. This is why many might leave the church or religion.

Back to the topic.

Stupidity is not always sin.

This led me to thinking more about sin. Sin is always stupid. No matter what, sin is stupid. Sin leads to hurting yourself or others in some way.

Stupid decisions aren’t necessarily sins. Sins are always stupid decisions.

This is one of the reasons God has given us this life. It’s a training ground. It’s a chance to prove ourselves worthy of more. If we can’t handle the trials and challenges of this testing ground, how can we be trusted with more in eternity?

I’m grateful for the life and the opportunity it gives me to be tested, with less at stake. My soul is safe. All my mistakes will be paid for by Christ, they have been paid for. I just need to turn to Him. I’m immensely grateful for that.